Timewalked
Sign in

Gut-check insights

How much do we actually agree?

Every vote from Rate a card, aggregated. This is where the pod's real opinions start justifying - or correcting - the bracket weighting already baked into the classifier.

  • 672
    Total votes
  • 15
    Players voted
  • 128
    Cards with 2+ votes
  • 22
    Days live

Pod arguments, quantified

Most controversial cards

Sorted by widest spread across numeric bracket_fit votes. Every vote is shown as a dot at its value - "any" votes are counted separately, off to the side.

  • Time Vault
    Spread 3

    3 votes · bracket_fit

  • Sylvan Scrying
    Spread 3

    3 votes · bracket_fit

  • Necropotence
    Spread 2

    4 votes · bracket_fit

  • Grand Arbiter Augustin IV
    Spread 2

    3 votes · bracket_fit

View all card ratings

Does the weighting hold up?

Category comparison

Average bracket_fit rating by curated category, numeric answers only. Sample sizes are shown next to every bar - a couple of these are still thin.

  • Mass Land Denial 3.90n=39
  • Fast Mana 3.88n=24
  • Notable Card Warnings 3.67n=3
  • Stax 3.46n=39
  • Repeatable Discard 3.40n=10
  • Closer Density 3.33n=6
  • Extra Turns 3.28n=25
  • Free/Alt-Cost Interaction 3.09n=11
  • Mass Mana 3.00n=4
  • Turn Skip 2.90n=10
  • Tutors 2.89n=27

Bars are scaled between 2.50-4.00, not the full 1-5 answer range, so the gap between categories is easier to read at a glance - exact averages are always shown at the right. Mass Land Denial, the highest-rated category, is highlighted.

The pod's overall lean

Overall answer distributions

All 672 votes, split by question type.

Bracket fit 382 votes

12345any

Commander power 114 votes

12345

The calm counterpart

Most agreed-upon cards

Same read as the controversial list above - this time, everyone's on the same page.

  • Mana Drain
    Spread 0

    5 votes · bracket_fit

  • Demonic Tutor
    Spread 0

    4 votes · bracket_fit

  • Devastating Dreams
    Spread 0

    4 votes · bracket_fit

  • Wildfire
    Spread 0

    4 votes · bracket_fit

Growing dataset

Votes over time

270 Sep 17 9 Sep 18 91 Sep 19 6 Sep 20 2 Sep 21 32 Sep 22 21 Sep 23 11 Sep 24 3 Sep 28 6 Sep 29 159 Oct 2 33 Oct 3 5 Oct 5 19 Oct 6 5 Oct 7

Still gathering signal

Calibration accuracy

3 of 14 calibration votes correct so far. Too early to mean much at this sample size - this becomes a real signal once more calibration cards get voted on.

From the pod

Recent notes

  • on Time Vault: “On its own, it's definitely nowhere near as strong as it could be. And although Bracket 4 allows for chaining extra turns, tutoring it and an untapper like Voltaic Key is far too easy. If it were ever unbanned for some reason, Bracket 5 is where it should stay.”
  • on Necropotence: “fuck this card in casual”
  • on Abdel Adrian, Gorion's Ward: “If it's in a dungeon deck, I'd assume it is in the deck for the two-card infinite and bump it to a B4.”
  • on Bloodchief Ascension: “I assume it'll come with the two-card infinite. If it doesn't, I'd drop it to a 3.”
  • on Toxrill, the Corrosive: “Its socially rude bracket 3 and below”
  • on Tergrid, God of Fright // Tergrid's Lantern: “Not friendly for casual environments.”